Classroom

Accommodating Difference

3843456676_50e65c393c_n
One of the panels I attended at this year’s CCCC explored issues of disability, access, and identity for students and faculty alike. The panelists viewed accommodation and disability as both challenges requiring creative solutions and opportunities for better understanding how people relate to the world around them.

This has me thinking about ways I can improve my own presentations—things I generally pride myself on doing well. I now realize my idea of a good presentation might be a complete failure for some members of an audience.
Full Post…
Comments

Managing Expectations

managing-expectations-slides.001
While interviewing teachers and students working with our first-semester outcomes-based writing course (built on the “writing about writing” curriculum), I discovered some surprising disparities among the perspectives of various stakeholders in the course-registration process. It seems the expectations of teachers, students, and the IT staff differ in substantial ways when it comes to offering face-to-face and online courses. When hybrid (or “mixed-mode” at my school) courses are added as an option, confusion and frustration can both develop. This discussion explores the need for better information dissemination to support student directed self-placement in courses implementing appropriate delivery modes.
Full Post…
Comments

Umbrella or Bridge

Umbrella or Bridge.001
This post is another in my growing series of presentation drafts. I’ll be giving this talk in Gainesville at UF’s Classroom Matters: Pedagogy in Practice and Philosophy writing conference. The purpose of this presentation is to emphasize the role and importance of discourse communities in an implementation of the writing about writing curriculum for first-year composition. I will be presenting conclusions from a task force at the University of Central Florida created to address a problem with student achievement identified through department-wide assessment of student portfolios. I will present the conclusions of this task force in terms of suggested revisions to the traditional Writing-about-Writing course sequence and proposed assignments to implement those revisions. Along the way, I will envision discourse communities through the lenses of complementary metaphors, those of an umbrella covering other elements of the curriculum and a bridge, establishing the connection between two other major units.
Full Post…
Comments

Built Beyond the Walls

beyond-the-walls
Here’s another post of thinking out loud before a conference presentation. This time, I’m discussion something I get quite excited by: applying MOOC philosophies to classroom-based education. For years, I’ve been frustrated by the trends in online learning, and I always felt that an LMS stripped away everything good about teaching. Last August, I got involved with the MOOC MOOC…and felt right at home.

In this talk, I take what I discovered in
MOOC MOOC (and MOOC MOOC²) and apply it to classrooms, showing that the characteristics which make cMOOCs awesome can actually work with traditional, in-person instruction. Early on, I introduce MOOCs and provide a very brief history, in case the term is new.
Full Post…
Comments

Intellectual Capital in FYC

Knowledge-Making
From the Department of Thinking Out Loud on a Blog, here are some first-draft ideas I’ve had for a conference talk I’ll be presenting at the upcoming Globalization, Information, Policy & Knowledge Production (GIP& KP) Annual Meeting in Orlando. It’s an interdisciplinary conference designed to bring scholars and policy-makers together, so it’s a completely different audience than I’m accustomed to. Previously, I’ve only spoken to English/writing teachers and librarians.

That said, I know my ideas as they stand don’t address policy as clearly as they should; I even confess as much mid-paragraph at one point. But I’m trying to show how research-driven FYC courses can help students develop their sense of and store of intellectual capital. (The conference’s theme is “Challenges and Opportunities for Improving Intellectual Capital and Research Productivity.” Again, not my usual conference.)

In this post, I present my sketch of “From Knowledge-Seeking to Knowledge-Making: Improving Intellectual Capital in First-Year Composition Courses.” I welcome any comments, dissension, argument, or rejection at this point. I’ll be adding lit review in my next revision.

Full Post…
Comments

Striking up a Conversation

456611804_d638a680cb
Having spent nearly a dozen years in high-school classrooms where my goal was to get students ready for multiple-choice standardized tests, I became accustomed to the drill of asking questions of my students and getting them to provide correct answers. Now, starting my third semester teaching college writing courses, I’ve seen just how detrimental that approach can be. Last semester, one of my greatest frustrations grew from stilted class conversations. I found myself trying to get students to contribute and talk to one another, but they were reluctant and always looked to me for confirmation of their ideas. Today, I was determined to start the semester on a different trajectory.
Full Post…
Comments

Guiding Principles

5374308475_619de16a0a_n
This semester, I'm trying a bit of an experiment. I want to try and break apart FYC and see how much of the core principles of the course and my department can be preserved if I use the “same old, same old” assignments that are commonplace in our department but implement them in a very nonstandard way. I want to see whether my traditional teaching style limits the effectiveness of my college classroom. You see, I taught ninth-grade English for nearly a dozen years, and there, the difference between students and teachers is often a centerpiece of discipline, course design, and daily expectations. With that experience, it was easy for me to move into an FYC course and expect the same situation. After all, it's a required gen-ed course, and it's still English class, right?
Full Post…
Comments

Breaking FYC: Ripping the Insides

386303100_c7ed386a6b_n
Last month, I talked about breaking the walls of the university and allowing first-year composition to grow outside the classroom and into the open spaces of the Internet. My goal was to begin to think of first-year composition without bounds, without the circumscribing confines of a set classroom meeting time. I certainly was not advocating for a full-scale abandonment of traditional education, but I wanted to begin thinking of what our basic writing courses could do if we encourage them to exist beyond the classroom.

For this post, I want to focus my attention inward, rather than outward. What would happen if we questioned the core of a first year composition course while the boundaries are in flux? Could our courses still operate, how would they be structured, and what with their content be? After doing a little damage by breaking the outside of FYC, let's take some time to break apart the guts, too.

Full Post…
Comments

Grading, Assessment, or Feedback?

6060230693_47e70db7fa_n
Mark Barnes wrote on the education SmartBlog that teachers should use narrative feedback instead of grades. His excellent suggestions for providing feedback on student writing highlight a critical difference teachers must keep in mind as they plan how they want to grade their courses. Though the words feedback, assessment, and grading are often used interchangeably, they identify very different processes designed to achieve very different goals. Examining these differences can help provide clarity and priority in how a class is managed.
Full Post…
Comments

Outsourcing Grading

2344294338_0014f8ac4b_z
A recent post to the Writing Program Administrators email listserv questions how grading works in a MOOC. The post’s author, Ed White, says that the goals of grading are to sort students and to help students self-assess. He goes on to observe that “some MOOCs seem to be ambiguous about both purposes.” I have to agree, but I think he’s understating the issue. The American obsession with standardized, “objective” tests has created an unhealthy focus/reliance on grades in our classes. On one hand, grades are essential; on the other, they can be corrosive and distracting. Can classes improve if we remove grading from the picture?
Full Post…
Comments

Defining a Discipline: Threshold Concepts as Lines of Demarcation

4269225669_b4550f58e9
How do you know when you’ve become a part of a group of people? How can you tell that you’ve been accepted and actually fit in? What is it that switches you from outsider to member?

In 2006, Jan Meyer and Ray Land published a book that addresses these issues and highlights some of the implications those questions have on how we teach students, especially in higher education. If we want to help students become members of a professional working group, shouldn’t we be able to tell when they’ve made it in?

A recent conversation in my department addressed our questions from this text, and we found ourselves questioning the essence of our discipline and asking what it is that makes rhetoricians/compositionists a distinct group of thinkers. These issues are not as simple to work through as you might think.
Full Post…
Comments

Orchestrating a Course

MP900409110
Today marks the beginning of the week before school starts for many of our nation’s colleges (including mine). That means students are busy buying books, finding classrooms, and moving into dorms. That also means teachers are preparing syllabi for their upcoming classes. In a conversation I had yesterday evening, a question came up about the balance of teaching versus facilitation in today’s online courses, and comments somewhat settled on teaching happening in the syllabus, allowing facilitation to fill the term. In this post, I dive into that balance/conclusion a little more. A conversation from the MOOC MOOC course I’m exploring got me wondering about the differences between teaching and facilitation, and how the two play out in an online course.
Full Post…
Comments

Showing the Work of Technology

Is the design of technology more like a mathematics problem or a humanities essay? Should we show our work or present only a final draft?
Full Post…
Comments

The Acceptability of Ignorance

Is it ever possible that ignorance, beyond allegedly being bliss, could be a good thing? What about for teachers?
Full Post…
Comments

On Rubrics. Or, Do We Know What We Want?

An assignment I’m working with—the final project for Comp II—is causing me grief when it comes to assessment. One of my peers refers to me as “The Rubric Guy” because I am, in a word, obsessed with the use of rubrics for major writing assignments. For years, I have relied on a detailed, multi-column rubric to help make my assessment more consistent and my expectations more clear.

What I’ve found is that a rubric can help make my expectations more clear
to me before I ever give the assignment to my students. As I’ve developed my Comp I and Comp II classes this year, I’ve never been comfortable with an assignment until I’ve finished its rubric; that’s how I know I understand what I’m expecting my students to do.

I’d like to discuss that process and the rationale behind rubrics in the face of some hearty opposition.

Full Post…
Comments

Between Print and Web: Digital Portfolios

Many English composition classes currently use portfolios as a means of assessment. These involve countless sheets of paper and some very large staples to collect student work into a single representative document. Some teachers are transitioning to ePortfolios, in which students build a website to host their portfolios, often as a series of individual PDFs.

Based on a poster presentation from last week, I propose a middle ground: digital portfolios that retain the single-document approach of a familiar traditional portfolio, but using documents that employ more advanced design elements to take advantage of the electronic medium.

Full Post…
Comments

Let's Go Back…to the Future

Wrapping up a collection of recent comments on the promising or problematic nature of technological developments in education, I argue that what was thought back in the 1940s should be brought back to our attention, and that the technological developments of the past 40 years have served to distract that attention from the real business of learning: the work and the content.
Full Post…
Comments

On Engagement. Or, What Makes Learning Real?

Teachers often crave students who are “engaged” with their learning, and new technologies often flaunt how “engaged” they get students to be. But are we really setting the right expectations for our education system, and are those really the goals we should have for our tech (or our students)?
Full Post…
Comments

The Sound of Productivity

After reading an article about the merits of working from coffee shops, I find myself wondering whether the working environment of classrooms are as authentic as we think.
Full Post…
Comments

Putting Schoolwork on Refrigerator Doors

If we work to make classrooms more like the “real world” outside schools, where will grades come from? How can we be sure everyone participates? How can we be sure everyone learns?
Full Post…
Comments

Testing, Testing: 1…2…3?

Our nation’s schools are obsessed with grades and tests. But where in the world (no…literally) is the concept of formal testing used outside the education institution? Why do we accept “good enough” as sufficient to graduate?
Full Post…
Comments

Making Students Bloom: What Can They Create?

New advances in technology are making me reconsider which steps of Bloom’s taxonomy we need to pay attention to. As computers are able to do more for us, the nature of our education goals need to change accordingly.
Full Post…
Comments

Counting Words

Throughout our educational careers, we are taught to count words as a measure of completeness for our writing. But why? And what qualities of writing end up taking priority?
Full Post…
Comments

When Does the Criticism Start?

A recent class conversation got me pondering the scarcity of critical thinking in our culture.
Full Post…
Comments

Thinking Allowed/Aloud

Here, I explain the title of the blog.
Full Post…
Comments